Res no pot vèncer tires LED adreçables if you want greater control over your LED lighting! But which protocol is better to control these addressable LED strips- DMX512 or SPI?
DMX512 and SPI are two different communication protocols used in addressable LED strips. One is a standardized protocol ideal for large-scale professional installation; the other is more suitable for DIY and small to medium-scale projects. Though DMX512 addressable LED strips are expensive and complex to set up, they are more durable and reliable for long-distance control.
However, both variants have their own benefits and drawbacks to consider. So, here I bought you a detailed discussion on DMX512 addressable LED strip Vs. SPI addressable LED strip to help you pick the one best for your project:
Taula de continguts Amaga
What Is DMX512 Addressable LED Strip?
Working Mechanism Of DMX512 Addressable LED Strip
What Is an SPI Addressable LED Strip?
Working Mechanism Of SPI Addressable LED Strip
DMX512 VS. SPI Addressable LED Strip: Differences
Quick Comparison Chart: DMX512 VS. SPI Addressable LED Strip
Which Is Better For Your Project: DMX512 Or SPI LED Strips?
Preguntes freqüents
La línia de base
Articles Relacionats
What Is DMX512 Addressable LED Strip?
DMX512 addressable LED strips use the DMX512 (3-wire control mode) protocol to control individual LEDs populated along the LED strip length. It is a globally recognized standard for controlling lighting and its effect on digital communication networks.
While standard LED strips show one color at a time, Cintes LED adreçables DMX512 can bring up multiple colors throughout the strips. Thus, you can adjust each LED chip’s brightness and color, making DMX512 addressable LED strips suitable for stage, architecture, and event lighting.
More impressively, you can cut these strips to a specific length per your installation requirements. Though all these features make DMX512 addressable LED strips more expensive than regular ones, they are investment-worthy, changing the entire vibe of your space!
Working Mechanism Of DMX512 Addressable LED Strip
The components behind the magic of these Tires LED are the Driver IC and DMX Controller. Unlike regular LEDs, each cut in these strips has a DMX512 IC that makes them addressable. It allows the DMX512 IC to receive and interpret data to control the color and brightness of LED.
First, the DMX controller sends a digital signal following the DMX512 protocol. This signal is a series of packets that can send 512 data packets each time. Every packet consists of 11 bits appointed for a specific task.
| DMX512 packet structure (11 bits) | |||
| característica | Descripció | Nombre deBits | Interval de valors |
| Bit inicial | Marks the beginning of a new packet | 1 | 0 (Logical Low) |
| Bytes de dades | Contains brightness information for a specific channel in 256 levels to a brightness range of 0% to 100% | 8 | 0 (off) to 255 (full brightness) |
| Stop Bits | Signals the end of the packet | 2 | Both 1 (Logical High) |
NB: “Logical Low” refers to 0 volts, and “Logical High” refers to the voltage level defined by the DMX standard (usually around 5 volts).
Each of these packets contains an address code. The DMX512 IC receives the incoming signals and scans for the unique address assigned to its section of the LED strip. Once it finds the right packet, the IC extracts the data byte, which contains the color and brightness information. Following the data, the IC adjusts the power delivered to the red, green, and blue (or white) sub-diodes within each LED. Thus, by controlling the power supply, the IC determines the resulting color and brightness of the LED. This way, you will get color variation in different LED strip segments that follow specific instructions.
Pros & Cons Of DMX512 Addressable LED Strip
Pros:
Long-distance transmission: DMX512 addressable LED strips transmit data by measuring the voltage difference between two wires. This favors long cable runs, avoiding unwanted electrical interferences. You can also use DMX signal repeaters for longer distances. This device amplifies the DMX signal, refreshes it, and maintains its signal strength over extended cable lengths.
Standardized Protocol: Being a standard protocol, DMX is widely used by different brands. Your devices can often seamlessly communicate. This way, you will have flexibility in choosing products rather than depending on any particular brand. You can easily integrate them with your existing DMX-based equipment.
Escalabilitat: Each DMX universe can control up to 512 channels! This allows a DMX512 addressable LED strip to control numerous individual LEDs within the strip length. And you can easily add extra universes when you need more capacity. Besides, these LED strips also support daisy-chaining. This means you can quickly extend the length by connecting multiple strips in series using just one DMX cable. This boosts the scalability and makes DMX512 addressable LEd strips suitable for large projects.
Independent Control: DMX signals operate in parallel. So, by chance, if one of the LED chips gets damaged, it won’t affect the operation of other ICs. Thus, you can have a seamless lighting experience even in long runs of LED strips.
Contres:
Configuració més complexa: You need technical knowledge about DMX programming while setting up a DMX512 addressable LED strip. It requires dealing with DMX controllers, so you must be familiar with the functions. This complicates the process compared to regular LED strips, which you can control via your phone or remote.
Lower LED Density: DMX521 addressable LED strips have IC chips on the PCB, unlike the built-in IC in SPI. This is why they often have lower density; you will get fewer LEDs per meter than regular or SPI LED strips. These strips may not be ideal for high-resolution lighting effects.
Lower Voltage per LED: DMX521 addressable LED strips usually group multiple LEDs under a single voltage. For example- 12V for 3 LEDs per pixel and 24V for 6 LEDs per pixel. This can limit the brightness control of an individual chip due to having multiple LEDs connected to a single voltage source.
Corba d'aprenentatge: You must learn the DMX technology to operate the DMX512 addressable LED strips. Understanding its functions and learning about troubleshooting is essential before using these fixtures. To learn more, check this- Tot el que necessiteu saber sobre el control DMX512.
What Is an SPI Addressable LED Strip?
SPI stands for ‘Interfície perifèrica en sèrie.’ It is a synchronous communication protocol that transfers data between integrated circuits (ICs) like microcontrollers and peripheral devices. An SPI addressable LED strip uses SPI protocol to control individual LEDs of addressable LED strips. The strips directly receive the SPI signals and adjust the color and brightness of the LEDs accordingly.
It transfers more than 512 values of DMX and can control over 1000 individual RGB LED pixels. But unfortunately, it is not a standardized protocol like the DMX512. Different types of SPI LEDs exist, such as WS2811 or TM1914 LED strips. So, you need to set the correct SPI protocol for your addressable LED strips while installing.
Working Mechanism Of SPI Addressable LED Strip
Each LED of SPI addressable LED strips has an IC chip that controls individual LEDs. Following the SPI protocol, a microcontroller sends data signals to these IC chips. These signals consist of a serial data line (DI) and a clock line (CI) for synchronization.
The data packs contain the color and brightness information for every LED within the LED strips. The first LED in the series receives the data pack, reads the specified data, and forwards the remaining data to the next LED. This way, the IC chips of all LEDs receive their instruction and adjust the color and brightness accordingly.
In this case, they use Pulse Width Modulation (PWM) to adjust the intensity of the red, green, and blue channels. Thus, they ensure individual control over the LEDs, facilitating dynamic lighting.
Pros & Cons Of SPI Addressable LED Strip
Pros:
Simpler setup: SPI addressable LED strips are very easy to set up as they require two wires: a data line and a clock line. Unlike DMX512, you do not need high technical knowledge to set these up.
Higher refresh rates: These LED strips generally allow for higher refresh rates. Thus, you get smoother dimming and color changes without visible flickering.
High control per LED: SPI addressable LED strips allow greater control over LEDs. They can achieve 24-bit color depth, allowing for 16,777,216 (2^24) color shades per LED. This provides the SPI addressable LED strips with greater control over LEDs.
Cost-efectiu: These LED strips are less expensive than DMX512 addressable LED strips. This makes them suitable for small installations. However, you can also chain them to increase their length.
Contres:
Escalabilitat limitada: The microcontrollers or control systems of SPI protocol have limitations on the number of LEDs they can control. Thus, for large installations, you will require multiple controllers. Besides, with the increase in length, the power distribution becomes more complex, which can cause severe voltage drop issues. This makes SPI-addressable LED strips not the best choice for larger installations.
Non-standardized protocol: SPI is not a standardized protocol. So, you may have compatibility issues with the integration. Different manufacturers use slightly varying configurations in developing their products. Integrating SPI addressable LED strips with third-party lighting control systems, software, or hardware can make it more challenging.
Signal transmission issues: The SPI signals are transmitted serially. If any IC is damaged, it will affect the following transmission signals. However, some SPI LED strips have backup signals to solve these issues. It bypasses some ICs by carrying the same signal following a different path within the strip.
DMX512 VS. SPI Addressable LED Strip: Differences
Though DMX512 and SPI give you greater control over addressable LED strips, there are some significant differences. These are as follows:
Protocol de comunicació
DMX512 addressable LED strip uses a standardized protocol, DMX512. It uses a daisy-chain configuration with a master-slave architecture. The DMX512 addressable LED strip data is transmitted in 512-channel frames called universes. Each of these universes can control up to 512 channels. DMX works excellently for long-distance communication thanks to its robustness in data transfer.
On the contrary, SPI addressable LED strips follow a synchronous serial communication protocol, SPI. It is a common yet non-standardized protocol used in various electronic devices. It transmits data serially, so any damage to any IC can affect the corresponding ones. These LED strips are ideal for short-distance but not suitable for long runs.
Capacitat de control
In a DMX512 system, a single DMX channel controls multiple LEDs by grouping them. For example, it can control 3 LEDs (red, green, and blue) with a single DMX channel or create a group of 3 LEDs and have 3 DMX channels, one for each color. Thus, all the LEDs in a group will have the same color and brightness level. This minimizes the control over individual LEDs. So, individual control is not possible.
In SPI addressable LED strips, you get better control over individual LEDs as each has an integrated control circuit (IC). Thus, it receives varying data for every LED from the SPI communication protocol, allowing greater control over individual LEDs. It usually uses 24 bits per LED (8 bits for each red, green, and blue channel). You can bring more variation to the lighting effect.
Sol·licitud
DMX512 addressable LED strips are suitable for large projects. You can use them for stage, theater, architectural lighting, TV, film production, nightclubs, and entertainment venues. The standardized protocol used in these strips makes them suitable for professional application.
In contrast, SPI Addressable LED Strips are suitable for small installations where individual LED control is essential. They offer greater flexibility and are easy to customize. You can use these lights for signage, retail lighting, interactive art, and wearable technology. Besides being cost-effective, you can use them for low-budget projects.
Power Consumption: Energy Efficiency
Usually, DMX512 addressable strips run at higher voltage configurations by grouping multiple LEDs. Such grouping needs high power consumption. Besides, the overall signal processing in DMX is complex. It further deals with multiple hardware like DMX controllers, signal repeaters, etc. All these require more power consumption than SPI. However, the overall power consumption depends on factors such as LED density, brightness levels, and voltage configurations.
SPI addressable LED strips have a built-in IC chip that allows power consumption only to specific LEDs. That is, power will be consumed only by the active LEDs. Such independent control makes these strips more energy efficient than DMX512 addressable LED strips. However, LED density and voltage should be considered while comparing their power consumption.
Installation Scale: Size Of The Project
You can easily use DMX512 addressable LED strips to project requiring control over thousands of LEDs. They are compatible to use with multiple DMX universes for extensive lighting installations. Besides, grouping LEDs allows you to control a large section of LEDs altogether. This makes them suitable for large projects like- stage and architectural lighting.
As SPI relies on a clock line to synchronize data transmission, longer distances can result in data accuracy. In this case, maintaining synchronization can be difficult. SPI addressable LED strips are ideal for small to medium-scale projects.
Facilitat d'instal·lació
You can easily use DMX512 addressable LED strips to project requiring control over thousands of LEDs. They are compatible to use with multiple DMX universes for extensive lighting installations. Besides, grouping LEDs allows you to control a large section of LEDs altogether. This makes them suitable for large projects like- stage and architectural lighting.
As SPI relies on a clock line to synchronize data transmission, longer distances can result in data accuracy. In this case, maintaining synchronization can be difficult. SPI addressable LED strips are ideal for small to medium-scale projects.
Durabilitat
DMX512 addressable LED strips are designed for professional use. They usually have higher IP and IK ratings to resist outdoor and industrial environments. Besides, they have better soldering, stronger PCB, and robust coating. Apart from all these physical features, The DMX512 signals are highly resistant to electrical noise and interference. This makes DMX512 systems more durable for industrial-level installation. Yet, the durability depends on the brand or manufacturer.
In contrast, SPI addressable LED strips, mainly used in small indoor and creative projects, may not have higher IP ratings. These fixtures limit the resistance level to the hash environment outside. Besides, the cascading issues also affect the durability of the fixture. If one of the IC chips gets damaged, the corresponding LEDs will be affected.
Costant
DMX512 addressable LED strips are expensive as they are of professional grade and made of high-quality material. Besides, it requires additional equipment like controllers, signal repeaters, and cabling for large installations. All these factors increase the initial cost of DMX512 addressable LED strips. However, they will save you money in the long term as they don’t require much maintenance.
SPI addressable LED strips are available in various qualities and at various prices. You will get the consumer-grade strips at a cheaper price compared to the DMX512 strips. However, in the long run, maintenance costs may be higher due to cascading issues. Besides, they will not offer you the same performance and durability as the DMX512 addressable LED strips.
Quick Comparison Chart: DMX512 VS. SPI Addressable LED Strip
| Criteris | Tira LED adreçable DMX512 | Tira LED adreçable SPI |
| Protocol de control | DMX512 addressable LED strips use DMX512 (Digital Multiplex) protocol. It is a digital communication network used to control a wide range of devices, including LED strips. | SPI Addressable LED strips use SPI (Serial Peripheral Interface) protocol. It is a synchronous serial communication interface. |
| Standardized protocol | Sí | no |
| Addressing Capabilities | A single DMX512 universe can support up to 512 channels. For example, a RGB LED has three channels (red, green, and blue), so one DMX512 universe can control 170 RGB LEDs individually. You can further add more DMX512 universes to control more LEDs. | There is no fixed channel capacity; the controller and LED IC used in the strip determine the number of LEDs that can be controlled. This can go from a hundred to a thousand LEDs, depending on the controller capacity. |
| Escalabilitat | Large scale project | Small to medium scale project |
| Redacció de codi | It requires code writing, which complicates the process. | No code writing is required. |
| densitat LED | DMX512 addressable LED strips have lower LED density than SPI strips. | SPI addressable LED strips have higher density. That is, you will get more LEDs per meter than DMX. |
| Sol·licitud | Large indoor and outdoor projects like- stage, architectural, and event lighting | Small spaces and consumer electronics, DIY projects, wearable technology, and decorative lighting. |
| Distància del cable | These are suitable for long distances, and the cable length can extend up to 300m. However, signal degradation may occur after a certain distance in practical application. To overcome this, you need to install signal boosters or repeaters. | SPI addressable LED strips are suitable for short-distance communication, and the recommended cable distance for optimal performance is <1M. This can vary for different IC capabilities. Nevertheless, with proper signal conditioning, long distance is also possible. |
| Estructura del cable | 3 wires (DMX+, DMX-, GND) | 2 wires (Data, GND) |
| Velocitat de transmissió de dades | Has a low data transmission speed of 250kHz. These addressable LED strips are suitable for installation where timing is not crucial. | They have higher transmission speeds of 400kHz and 2MHz. You can use them in applications where rapid changes in lighting effects are required. |
| Control Granularity | The granularity of control is limited to the group level, and individual control of each LED is not possible. | SPI addressable LED strips allow individual control over LEDs. |
| Complexitat | Setting up a DMX512 LED strip is complex. You need technical knowledge about DMX controllers, adding signal repeaters, etc. | It is a widely used protocol, and you can easily set up SPI addressable LED strips. |
| Common Voltages | DMX512 strips can operate at various voltages, including 5V, 12V, and 24V. High voltage, like 24V, is ideal for long runs. | SPI strips commonly operate at 5V or 12V. For long strips, you may need to inject power to avoid voltage drop. |
| Cost | As DMX512 addressable LED strips require a DMX controller and additional hardware, it has high initial costs. However, their maintenance cost is minimal. | The initial cost of an SPI addressable LED strip is reasonable. They use inexpensive SPI controllers and microcontrollers, which are affordable. |
Which Is Better For Your Project: DMX512 Or SPI LED Strips?
In choosing the right addressable strip for your project, you must consider your requirements first. If you are working on a large-scale project, Cintes LED adreçables DMX512 are your best choice. They are durable and designed for professional installations. You can set them for stage lighting, building, or outdoor event lighting.
Another benefit of using DMX512 addressable LED strips is that it is an international standard protocol. Using the same DMX512 controller can support different types of DMX512 ICs. Thus, you will have more flexibility when using these strips for your project. However, all these extended facilities make DMX512 addressable strips expensive. So, you need to have a good budget to install these fixtures.
Nevertheless, SPI addressable LED strips are good to go if you are into DIY tasks or any small-to-medium project. These are simple to install; any beginner can set them up without much technical knowledge. However, a significant drawback is that SPI is not a standardized protocol. This means that not all SPI controllers are compatible with every SPI IC. Nevertheless, they are very budget-friendly solutions compared to DMX addressable LED strips.
So, considering all these factors, you can quickly decide the best one for your project. For further guidance, read The Ultimate Guide To Addressable LED Strip.
Preguntes freqüents
What is the main difference between DMX and SPI addressable LED light strips?
DMX and SPI are two different communication protocols. DMX addressable LED strips are designed for long-distance communication and are suitable for large-scale installations. In contrast, SPI LED strips are great for precise control over individual LEDs. You can use them for short-distance communication in small to medium projects.
What is the average lifespan of DMX and SPI LED light strips?
The lifespan of LED strips depends on several factors. This includes quality, construction materials, and fixture maintenance. Yet, on average, DMX and SPI LED strips can last from 30,000 to 50,000 hours.
Are SPI LED light strips more energy-efficient than DMX ones?
DMX LED strips deal with complex signal processing and multiple hardware usage. This can increase the power consumption. In contrast, SPI LED strips involve fewer components and less circuitry for communication. Besides, the signal processing is also simple, requiring less power consumption than DMX. Thus, SPI LED strips are more energy efficient than DMX.
Can I integrate addressable LED light strips with my existing smart home system?
You can integrate addressable LED strips with your smart home system. However, the integration method varies for DMX and SPI. You need a Wi-Fi/Ethernet connection to the DMX controller for the DMX LED strips. You can integrate them into your system through a smart home hub or bridge. For SPI addressable LED strips, you need a controller. It must be compatible with Zigbee, Z-Wave, Wi-Fi, or Bluetooth.
Are there any color limitations with DMX or SPI LED light strips?
There are no color limitations with MX, or SPI LED light strips. They can produce a wide range of colors, typically in the millions. To choose any of these, consider factors. These include control needs, installation complexity, and application requirements. Don’t focus on color limits.
Is 512 channels of DMX enough?
Whether 512 channels of DMX are enough depends on specific requirements. Simple RGB requires three channels per LED; RGB requires four channels. Again, multiple channels will be needed if you are lighting moving head fixtures. For small to medium projects, 512 channels are enough. But, if 512 channels don’t meet your needs for large installations, you can expand DMX channels.
Can you cut DMX512 channel LED strips?
Yes, DMX512 channel LED strips have cut marks, following which you can cut them. Based on LED density and voltage, they are available in different cut lengths like- 16.66mm, 100mm, or 50mm. You can choose the one that fits your requirements most. However, smaller cut lengths give you better size flexibility. Besides, be careful while cutting the strips. A wrong cut can damage the LED.
Can DMX LED light strips be used outdoors?
DMX LED strips are designed for outdoor usage. They are available in higher IP ratings that resist dust and water contact. So, you can use them in scorching sun or extreme rainfall and storms. Be cautious. Check the outdoor gradings of the fixture before buying it.
How do I know if I use an SPI or a DMX addressable LED strip?
The best way to identify the addressable LED strip you use is to check the packaging. If that’s not possible, check the wirings and connectors of your addressable LED strips. SPI LED strips use a straightforward wiring arrangement. Meanwhile, DMX LED strips are usually connected to the control via XLR or RJ45 connectors. But if you can’t differentiate them apart, look for the manufacturer info on Google.
La línia de base
Done with your decision or need more guidance? Let me sum up: DMX512 addressable LED strip Vs. SPI addressable LED strip for you. If you have a high budget and need professional-level installation, go for DMX512 addressable LED strips. This globally recognized protocol will expand flexibility in integrating your fixture with third-party devices. Besides, in DMX512, addressable strip signals are sent in parallel. So, if one LED is ruined, the other will not affect its performance. They are great for theatrical, stage, concert, event, exhibition, film, and production lighting.
However, purchase SPI addressable LED strips if you need more precise control over LEDs. They allow you to control the color brightness and effect of every single LED strip on the PCB. This makes them ideal for digital signage, TV & monitor integrations, interactive art lighting, and more. The simple and quick setup further makes them suitable for DIY projects.
Whichever you choose between DMX512 and SPI addressable LED strips, LEDYi is your ultimate LED strip supplier. We offer you a customization facility for both variants. We can provide tires LED adreçables with IP52(silicone coating), IP65(silicone tube), IP65H(heat shrink tube), IP67(silicone filling), IP67E(silicone extrusion), IP68(PU encased) or anything as per your need. We also offer customization facilities for these products’ voltage, power consumption, dimension, shape, length, and packing. So, why wait any longer? Contact us ASAP!
Articles Relacionats
La guia definitiva per a la tira LED adreçable
Tira LED CSP VS Tira LED COB
Com funcionen les tires LED?
Com connectar llums de tira LED (diagrama inclòs)
Tot el que necessiteu saber sobre el control DMX512
Control d'il·luminació DMX vs. DALI: quin triar?
Tot el que necessiteu saber sobre la regulació DALI
RGB vs. RGBW vs. RGBIC vs. RGBWW vs. RGBCCT LED Strip Lights
Tira LED CSP VS Tira LED COB
